General

Maplesword art online

Here is a scenario,

maplestory was made into a virtual reality game, and people were hooking up to the machines on the day it came out.
However, nexon decided that it will be more profitable if they trapped every player in ms and make it so that if you try to leave the game, your brain gets fried by the VR machine.
Also, if you die in the game, your brain also gets fried.
So basically, you are fighting for your life, and to leave the game, someone (or a group) must be able to beat Corrupted Empress Cygnus (I think she's the highest level boss).
Also, players can attack other players in maps more than 3 maps away from major cities. So miners, trainers, bossers, and the kind all have a certain amount of risk, not only from monsters, but from other players.

Which class would you pick?
Would you be a solo player or a party player?
Will you be generally good? evil? or neutral?

Good
You will join a guild or a group that is bent on beating the game and/or being helpful to other players and preventing PKs from taking place.
Order is your greatest virtue

Evil
You will be Player Killing for money, power, men (or women lol), or for the sheer fun of killing.
Chaos and . . .wait, you have no virtue

Neutral
Mining, crafting, forging, and merching (although merching borders evil) is your trade, and you will help either side, as long as you survive at the end.
Being neutral, doesn't mean being weak, you can freely choose to attack or help others.
Greed and character interaction are your favorite attributes.

UPDATE1: talk is cheap, lets say you found you godly weapon from a monster drop for your class and you now have a huge damage advantage towards your peers. Would you still be good/evil/neutral?

UPDATE2: for every little prick that says THERES NO MAGIC IN SAO LOLONEONE11, no crap Sherlock. but MSAO =/= SAO, and i certainly don't want to cut out all the magic using classes in ms. so why dont you buzz off.

P.S. and before noobs go like IMA STEAL MY DADS CREDIT CARD LOL, there is no nx in this game.

For the sake of fun, fatal, gameplay, these skills have been disabled
Divine Shield: Paladin
Resurrect: Bishop
That-phantom-skill-that-prevents-KO: Phantom
Soul Stone: Evan

For the sake of a clean, trollless thread, the following has been enabled
-flame shield on-

TLDR: crap hit the fan, you're fighting for your life in ms, what are you going to do.
Some of my favorites so far

@Maylive
YakHunter
76 Bera Hunter
Hero will have enough HP, can make other stronger with one rage! I'm strong too. I'll smash all the monsters with my Two handed deadly axe.
Good-I'll help people and build up a huge family and guild of maplers that want to kill the crazy empress!
I'll never lose hope, and I'll never scamm people, will always help. I might not have much mesos, so I wont be as strong as the evil merchant, but me and 3 of my friends will be enough to kick any ONE else
One day I might die, but not before I'll do it, so my principles will pass to my juniors and my guild will remember me forever True HERO!

Just kidding , I can say for sure that I'll be a F/P wizard. Neutral, Having fun, reading, learning, YOLO in this maple world
why Fire and poison? making smart traps, see my enemies suffer. why mage? cuz that's what I like, learning.
I will discover new areas all over the maple world, and I won't be famous.
will work at the accessory forge. Have some friends, good ones, and I will trust them with my life I'll join the guild "Math freaks".
Phantoms will steal my skills for sure, but hey! I'm the only one who really know how to use them.
Live long enough to see the empress die by my past self, the one who wrote the first paragraph.

Yeah, that's basically it.

@alectrick001
KikBublegum 152 Khaini Mechanic 4
mechanic
party squad type
good im a part of the frontline soldiers im tank driver what can i say

people better watch out i dont have a drivers license ;p

Kaboom! the end

@Demonlord
AsuyaYin 50 Bera Blade Acolyte
OT:
A Dark Knight solo player on the evil side. Not a massacre kinda PKer, but I don't hold back when I want to kill. No women though. I'd never lay my weapon on a woman, just my hands.

People actually chose Evil, as a PKer? Pft, None of you have the guts to kill anyone(Or maybe I'm giving this too much of a serious thought).

@kloana
iLionion 126 ElNido Bishop

Here's my run down. I'd be chaotic neutral. I'd never go out of line of the normal, but I definitely wouldn't pass a chance to get ahead in the game, even if it meant to do something bad.

I'd definitely be a Dark Knight. I love spears, Dark Knights have good access to health, and they definitely have some good party support.
I'd run a party to have power in numbers, I'd be with people I trust, and can support me.
We would definitely not stray to attack someone we knew we could take, provided there was gain to it.
I'd craft doing mining and armoring while my friends watched my back while gathering, I'd gear my party.
I'd also sell things I made not for profit, but for trust with other people, I like to play the sneaky fox approach.
"Everyone wants one, but it's not good to keep around."
Under the circumstance that I got a godly weapon I would become very chaotic neutral. I'd still support my party, but I wouldn't let anything get in my way.
I would love to get my friends out of there, even if it meant killing people that we came across.
Per say a poor shad was sitting at empress waiting for a group, we'd take him out to take anything he has that can help us.

I would never back out of a challenge, and I wouldn't let myself fall, but I'd support the people who helped me.

August 19, 2012

103 Comments • Newest first

DistantSky

[quote=phanblow]Oh Mah Gawd, SAO <3
I would be� a hero, solo player (but not for bosses) and i would be good.

EDIT: I would use a one-handed sword, with no shield for higher mobility.[/quote]

cough cought ismelllkiritosdualbladeskill cough

Reply September 13, 2012
SanjuPM

wait i though SAO had no classes to pick* and you just chose what type of route you wanted to become if so id definitively become a party player. Wheres the fun in being a solo

Reply September 11, 2012
phanblow

Oh Mah Gawd, SAO <3
I would be� a hero, solo player (but not for bosses) and i would be good.

EDIT: I would use a one-handed sword, with no shield for higher mobility.

Reply September 11, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=kloana]@LoveMeLater
Play dofus heroic server, teaches all of the above almost instantly.

Here's my run down. I'd be chaotic neutral. I'd never go out of line of the normal, but I definitely wouldn't pass a chance to get ahead in the game, even if it meant to do something bad.

I like the whole .hack set up we have here, just a slightly diff concept.

I'd definitely be a Dark Knight. I love spears, Dark Knights have good access to health, and they definitely have some good party support.
I'd run a party to have power in numbers, I'd be with people I trust, and can support me.
We would definitely not stray to attack someone we knew we could take, provided there was gain to it.
I'd craft doing mining and armoring while my friends watched my back while gathering, I'd gear my party.
I'd also sell things I made not for profit, but for trust with other people, I like to play the sneaky fox approach.
"Everyone wants one, but it's not good to keep around."
Under the circumstance that I got a godly weapon I would become very chaotic neutral. I'd still support my party, but I wouldn't let anything get in my way.
I would love to get my friends out of there, even if it meant killing people that we came across.
Per say a poor shad was sitting at empress waiting for a group, we'd take him out to take anything he has that can help us.

I would never back out of a challenge, and I wouldn't let myself fall, but I'd support the people who helped me.[/quote]

lmao, looks like you have this all planned out xD
its like, being one of those people who secretly hope for a zombie apocalypse huh

yeahh, I would totally not mind if something like this happened~

Reply August 31, 2012 - edited
NinjaOfTennis

I guess I'll take Evan, and party with my friends. Also, depends on your definition of good.

to do list...
--------------
1. Henehoe once I get to a high enough level.
2. Create a monopoly in the FM, everybody buys from me!
3. When I get bored, take my friends to empress, and before entering, add like 10 of that angelic burster that killed Zak in 4 seconds. WIN.

Reply August 31, 2012 - edited
chenglin

What is this? I'm going solo like Kirito

Reply August 31, 2012 - edited
PureWhiteSky

can anyone give the link for accel world?
cant seem to find it

Reply August 31, 2012 - edited
supersmash38

It's called Sword Art Online for a reason. Aren't you limited to only the Warrior swordsman class (Different branches too I suppose).

Reply August 29, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=ShadeCaro]@LoveMeLater: How long does it go to / go to so far?[/quote]

i think the anime is only up to ep 7, and i gave up reading the light novel at volume 3 because it turned boring.
idk about the manga

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=Demonlord]Though Volume 1 only had so much detail and the rest were kinda . . . sloppy(?).[/quote]

Sloppy, sure. But they skipped a bunch of key points in the adaptation.
http://www.baka-tsuki.org/project/index.php?title=SAO_Timeline
Lol, they removed chapter 16.5.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=ShadeCaro]Great, now I'm reading SAO.[/quote]

Please read the LNs. The side story adaptations that the anime does skipped over a lot of stuff.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=ShadeCaro]Great, now I'm reading SAO.[/quote]

sup adam xD
and dont read, watch the anime, it does a better job so far~

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
ShadeCaro

Great, now I'm reading SAO.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=Demonlord]@LoveMeLater: Which is why Klein is my favorite character. We need more Klein![/quote]

ikr! i swear hes the only average joe in the series xD

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@Demonlord: Yeah, I only followed the anime and up to the current one, it's been pretty good, I'd even go as far as one of the better for Summer '12. Thanks for the massive spoilers, now I only have crap to look foward to, lol </3

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=Yathos]@Demonlord: Yeah you can like a person for their personality. But like I said the writers went over the top. Haru is both unattractive and have low self-esteem... Please tell me a logical reason for Kuro to chose him out of everyone else.

As for SAO. ty for spoiling, but unlike you I have only watched up to ep 6 or 7.

Idk if it's just me, but from your post it seems like Kirito shoved something up your behind [/quote]

sorry for butting in, but one thing I dont like in SAO is that the goodcharacters that are actually introduced are like, hene hoe cute status (cept the black guy 0_o) and most evil guys are like, beyond hidious ==
i wish he uses a middle ground-ish character design~

/end ok, go back to your debate ^^

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
sano4444

sounds like .hack/sign to me. seems like it would be very fun

I'd go archer or warrior.
Party/solo doesnt really matter to me.
Neutral.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@Demonlord: Yeah you can like a person for their personality. But like I said the writers went over the top. Haru is both unattractive and have low self-esteem... Please tell me a logical reason for Kuro to chose him out of everyone else.

As for SAO. ty for spoiling, but unlike you I have only watched up to ep 6 or 7.

Idk if it's just me, but from your post it seems like Kirito shoved something up your behind

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=Demonlord]
@RisingRain: Him learning the . . crap what was it call. Reality breaker? No . . .the one where he can bend reality or something in Accel World. That was definitely spicy. I also wouldn't mind him getting a BA moment, but him actually trying to fight that new antagonist in real life using physical burst was some what BA. Too bad he lost, the author made the new antag really hate-able.[/quote]

Yeah, I like how new antagonists actually take some time and considerable effort to deal with them in AW. Yeah that moment, and the moment when he first got his wings were pretty good. If he'd won that Physical Burst fight with the antagonist, I'd think it'd be too easy. Though the whole blackmailing part was a bit eh on the realistic side for the antagonist. I don't think he'd honestly have that much power over the trio (excluding Kuro).

@Yathos His Brain Burst avatar is different. He's metal-colored, so that's already rare enough. You didn't miss that part where Kuro was talking about the colors and stuff right? And he's not invincible - he's really weak against puncture? attacks, and a lot of the antagonists use that effectively against him.
Of course he can only kick ass when he's in Brain Burst (and he doesn't always kick ass - he loses quite a bit in pivotal moments) - he's a fat pig in real life.
Taku's backstory - idk about that; the anime glossed over it and I didn't get much of it. I think Taku was just mad about Haru bringing up the whole kendo thing, as he's been cheating nonstop using Brain Burst the whole time. Not to mention Haru got a [b]bit[/b] close to his girlfriend.
http://8ths.in/accel-world-ep3-chiyu-h[e]ntai-fanservice/

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
xFluffymanx

This kind of sounds like Sword Art Online.... But they are probably not related at all... I think this is the wrong section too.

Solo, Bishop still. I can sell my HS for money and not spend money on healing crystals

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@RisingRain: I just want to make it clear that I haven't read the manga of either series and im currently on the lastest ep of each. So I'm judging each anime on what has happen thus far.

Ok the thing I have with Haru is that if the writers wanted him to be a 'different' why does Silver Crow have the prototypical protagonist physic and why is Haru only kicking ass when he is in Brain Buster? This is completely inconsistent on the writer's part.

Also with the whole friends thing, how does Taku turn evil then imediately switches back make any sense at all, if they are childhood friends. As for the relationship goes, like I said I don't have any manga knowledge and as far as I know Kirito x Asuna has the typical couple anime relationship.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=Yathos]The writers wanted to portray Haru as a loser who goes online and goes from zero to hero. They didn't have to go as far as turning into a Cartman. Also you talk about realism? How is it that a midget gets Taku and Chiyuri to be his friends and Kuro to fall for him? That is basically as unrealistic as it gets.
@DemonLord: You got to explain what's sissy about Kirito, he is as reckless as it gets in SAO. As for the realism part, Idc if Haru is not up to par with the standard anime physics, but making him a midget and having a pig avatar is completely ridiculous + the fact that he has two 'normal' friends makes it completely unrealistic...[/quote]

A midget and a pig avatar isn't ridiculous. It's just different from the norm.
And it's not exactly uncommon for a shut-in to have a few pretty close friends. Even all the shut-ins I know have a couple of really close friends.
Kuro falling for him was wish fulfillment for the author, I'll give you that. Except the author decided not to make it too unrealistic by having everything work out perfectly. Guess he learned something from writing SAO with Kirito and Asuna's "perfect" relationship.

@Demonlord The realism is what makes it more watchable than SAO. Though I wouldn't mind him having a few times when he gets [insert generic anime protagonist moment where he learns something and powers up for no explainable reason] to spice up the plot a bit.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

[quote=RisingRain]Explain #1, and #2 is actually somewhat realistic for a shut-in fat gamer nerd who has barely any social contact with anyone.[/quote]

The writers wanted to portray Haru as a loser who goes online and goes from zero to hero. They didn't have to go as far as turning into a Cartman. Also you talk about realism? How is it that a midget gets Taku and Chiyuri to be his friends and Kuro to fall for him? That is basically as unrealistic as it gets.
@DemonLord: You got to explain what's sissy about Kirito, he is as reckless as it gets in SAO. As for the realism part, Idc if Haru is not up to par with the standard anime physics, but making him a midget and having a pig avatar is completely ridiculous + the fact that he has two 'normal' friends makes it completely unrealistic...

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=Yathos]@RisingRain: I never thought "Haru gets all the crap he wants", I like the story of Accel World and it has a good pace so far, but I can't stand Haru for the following 2 reasons

#1 Writters completely over dramatized his character
#2 There are times were he PMS and goes complete emo mode.

I can't believe I'm saying this, but I think Even Emo Shu from GC is better than Haru...[/quote]

Explain #1, and #2 is actually somewhat realistic for a shut-in fat gamer nerd who has barely any social contact with anyone. His inferiority complex is annoyingly realistic, that's what I think. Sometimes I wish he'd just man up, but hey, he's getting better (somewhat...).

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@RisingRain: I never thought "Haru gets all the crap he wants", I like the story of Accel World and it has a good pace so far, but I can't stand Haru for the following 2 reasons

#1 Writters completely over dramatized his character
#2 There are times were he PMS and goes complete emo mode.

I can't believe I'm saying this, but I think Even Emo Shu from GC is better than Haru...

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
RisingRain

[quote=Yathos]@Demonlord: How is Kirito is sissy girl and where are the plot holes when the main story has yet to begin? Also who would want a fat kid that has a cyber pig avatar as the protagonist of a decent show?[/quote]

I'd prefer a beta who actually has to work to get what he wants (Haru) than an alpha who has everything cut out for him (Kirito). The plot armor on Kirito is INSANE.
[spoiler]He solos the admin, beats death in SAO (because he can't die for some BS reason), and rescues his girlfriend in another game using his same hax stats[/spoiler].

If you really think Haru gets all the crap he wants, you must've not watched Accel recently.

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@Demonlord: How is Kirito is sissy girl and where are the plot holes when the main story has yet to begin? Also who would want a fat kid that has a cyber pig avatar as the protagonist of a decent show?

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Icyflamez999

If you guys really like SAO, i suggest you guys read 1/2 prince it's pretty much the same concept but it's a girl that basically gets specially generated into a sexy male avatar LOL...

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
ixPiex

Job: Kaiser, Ds, or Luminous
Solo
Evil :>

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
klu180

*SPOILER*
TS, the last boss is the creator....so we have to fight some korean guy You know how good these people are at games.....we'd get owned

Reply August 22, 2012 - edited
Maylive

Hero <3 will have enough HP, can make other stronger with one rage! I'm strong too. I'll smash all the monsters with my Two handed deadly axe.
Good-I'll help people and build up a huge family and guild of maplers that want to kill the crazy empress!
I'll never lose hope, and I'll never scamm people, will always help. I might not have much mesos, so I wont be as strong as the evil merchant, but me and 3 of my friends will be enough to kick any ONE else
One day I might die, but not before I'll do it, so my principles will pass to my juniors and my guild will remember me forever True HERO!

Just kidding , I can say for sure that I'll be a [b]F/P wizard[/b]. Neutral, Having fun, reading, learning, YOLO in this maple world
why Fire and poison? making smart traps, see my enemies suffer. why mage? cuz that's what I like, learning.
I will discover new areas all over the maple world, and I won't be famous.
will work at the accessory forge. Have some friends, good ones, and I will trust them with my life I'll join the guild "Math freaks".
Phantoms will steal my skills for sure, but hey! I'm the only one who really know how to use them.
Live long enough to see the empress die by my past self, the one who wrote the first paragraph.

Yeah, that's basically it.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Baroo

I read--and bought--a novel pretty similar to this idea many years ago.
I think it was called Skymaze...

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Tore

I was waiting for this thread to pop up because I was also thinking about this as well.

Which class would you pick? Hero
Would you be a solo player or a party player? Solo (I've never relied on anyone to level up or get my items, it's all by myself.)
Will you be generally good? evil? or neutral? Good (because I like justice, I hate it when things are unfair)

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
whatheduck

Hene Hoe 4ever

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Metacafe

I'll craft/forge things but I'll give all the defective items to the bad side

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
vMinn

@LoveMeLater: I didn't realize that way.
I guess I'd try to be a party player, joining guild, having fun with others
And Maybe help those who are about to be pk'd by pker.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=TrisaChan]What happened to no magic? D: Someone didn't read SAO.[/quote]

well, maple isnt SAO, and im just taking the SAO virtual reality concept into ms.
screw no magic~

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
TrisaChan

What happened to no magic? D: Someone didn't read SAO.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
aeroarrowlol

Only way to win the game
BUY NX noty~

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=vMinn]Phantom
Solo player (I already am one tho)
Evil.

I'd go around PKing for my own entertainment.
Also, I wouldn't even bother defeating or beating the game.
Why would I wanna go back to real world, studying full time & part-time working/ online shopping mall
When I can make money just killing monsters for quest.[/quote]

Welll, theres a limit to how much you can pk
what if the entire maple population was killed by you~? it would be a boring game now wont it

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
vMinn

Phantom
Solo player (I already am one tho)
Evil.

I'd go around PKing for my own entertainment.
Also, I wouldn't even bother defeating or beating the game.
Why would I wanna go back to real world, studying full time & part-time working/ online shopping mall
When I can make money just killing monsters for quest.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Yathos

@TraceUserxBrawl: You might want to look up the definition of harem. The protagonist going from one girl to the next and ending with one. The girls are used as exposition to explain the mechanics of SAO or foil the protagonist's character/back-story. As for the plot holes, the main plot won't probably start until ep 12 or 13; also just because something is left out now and explained down the road, doesn't make it a plot hole...

I'm currently watching both and I prefer SAO, although Accel World has a more driven plot atm, but the character development is terrible.
Basically Accel World in a nutshell. Fat kids gets bullied => escapes to online world = > meets his dream girl = > Win. So cliche..

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Nyan

i would pick Phantom. i would steal peoples skills and i would be evil (HIT SHROULD WALK ARROW -> End of map Run, Town Scroll)

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
TraceUserxBrawl

[quote=LoveMeLater]whats accel about?[/quote]

http://myanimelist.net/anime/11759/Accel_World

Only bad thing is that the MC is fat.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
LoveMeLater

[quote=TraceUserxBrawl]I am. SAO is just a harem with plot holes right now.[/quote]

whats accel about?

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
TraceUserxBrawl

[quote=Yathos]Idk if you are serious?[/quote]

I am. SAO is just a harem with plot holes right now.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
redclaw202

I'd be a solo player, and I'll keep all the good training spots to myself.
Although I wasn't a beta tester, so I'm just a cheater.
And my class'd be Paladin, probably, even though there isn't a job system in SAO.

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Yathos

[quote=TraceUserxBrawl]Are you implying SAO is good?
Accel World is better.[/quote]

Idk if you are serious?

Reply August 20, 2012 - edited
Load more comments