General

Battlemage

BaM vs Kanna

just wondering if you guys think Kanna will be as good Better or Worse than Bam before hypers and after. and if someone has a link to kanna hyper skills please share.

Im thinking they will be worse in terms of damage output, possibly equal in terms of survivabilty, and maybe equal or slightly worse in party support.

bu i want to kno other Battle mages and mages thoughts on them

February 17, 2013

28 Comments • Newest first

Momijii

[quote=SombraManx]Gyouha is still their 1v1
youuan shoukan have a similar animation, and large range, that makes them similar
shads indeed have pretty nice survivability, but kanna and DS work similar (block chance, healing)
phantom skills is not AoE, like kanna's and DS
demons slayers summons demons: for expample in the hyper skill, cerberus, crrion breath and demon cry...

try them both, and you will see how similar they are.....

in fact, you couldn't be more wrong, its impossible[/quote]
Gyouha is Kanna's 1v1, but Demon Last isn't a Demon Slayer's true 1v1, that's Demon Impact.
That's not enough to make them similar since they have completely different functions.
You completely missed the point, try again.
Mille Aiguilles is AoE, sorry.
Not the same as Kanna since Kanna's are actually summons and Demon Slayer's are more of embellishment. Not to mention it's not even a summon since Demon Impact's description (for example) says "Call forth your inner demon." Can't really summon yourself.

I have a Demon Slayer and have played for a Kanna briefly. They have similarities, a few common "themes" (Spirit Power and Demon Fury, is one), but they don't play similarly at all.

You could not be more wrong, actually.

Reply February 24, 2013
SombraManx

@Momijii:

Gyouha is still their 1v1
youuan shoukan have a similar animation, and large range, that makes them similar
shads indeed have pretty nice survivability, but kanna and DS work similar (block chance, healing)
phantom skills is not AoE, like kanna's and DS
demons slayers summons demons: for expample in the hyper skill, cerberus, crrion breath and demon cry...

try them both, and you will see how similar they are.....

in fact, you couldn't be more wrong, its impossible

Reply February 24, 2013
Momijii

[quote=SombraManx]demon cry -like skill
ctrl spam skill
nice survivability (block chance, def, healing)
kanna summons demons and tengus, ds summons dark spirits
kanna and ds, both have an hurricane like skill that mobs
insane range![/quote]
Youuan Shoukan is not like Demon Cry. Their only similarity is their large aoe. Youuan does not reduce defense or increase EXP, all Youuan does is leave a DoT-cloud.
Shisen Gyouha does not replace Kanna's auto-attack like Demon Leash though. Not to mention Gyouha doesn't even restore Spirit Power like Leash restores Fury.
They have nice survivability, but then so do Shadowers.
I'm not sure where you're getting the notion that Demon Slayers summon anything. (There is no wording in any of his skill descriptions that allude to summoning.)
So do Phantoms.
Not much of a similarity at all since Kanna trashes Demon Slayer's range and Demon Slayer's "insane range" is limited to a handful of skills whereas almost all of Kanna's skills have an insane range.

Your reasoning is trash. Try again.

Reply February 24, 2013
SombraManx

[quote=Momijii]I don't get why people keep saying that she'll play just like a Demon Slayer.[/quote]

demon cry -like skill
ctrl spam skill
nice survivability (block chance, def, healing)
kanna summons demons and tengus, ds summons dark spirits
kanna and ds, both have an hurricane like skill that mobs
insane range!

Reply February 24, 2013
Blazetent

From what I've been told, BaM's are much stronger. But Kanna are better balanced, are good fun and have good skills.

Once I have a Kanna, I can compare it to my Bam

Reply February 24, 2013
MystChronic

BaM are alot more better especially with a higher dps. But no doubt the will be no nerf needed for kana but rather hayoto a class which combines db,bam, and another class.

Reply February 24, 2013
Singaporean

@Blohgorn:

Yeah i guess there will be 2 mag pally classes lol.

Reply February 24, 2013
Blohgorn

[quote=Singaporean]If anything, I feel that Kanna plays like a cannoneer+pally with all the counters and guards.... pally mage?[/quote]

Thought we were the mage version of pally with our max def and blue aurora lol

Reply February 23, 2013
Rionnon

B > Kanna Hurricane Buff!

Reply February 22, 2013
Singaporean

If anything, I feel that Kanna plays like a cannoneer+pally with all the counters and guards.... pally mage?

Reply February 22, 2013
fyeflowlight

[quote=toad]BaM lag with teleport? Im pretty sure its not true... [/quote]

What i meant is that every time after u execute tele, there's a delay before u can execute it again. (well, for me at least) and i was wondering if that delay is less, euqal or greater than 1s.

Reply February 20, 2013
missingpinky

[quote=Blohgorn]i dont see kanna being similar to ds play style. i see it being a mage that has a mille aiguilles type skill, with summons that make BaMs jealous. other than that i think they are really similar to BaM's with their close range combat playstyle. do you guys think their haja rengekifu (the mille tyle skill) will attacks faster then FB[/quote]

besides the massive amount of summons Kanna has,
She also has a wide variety of mobbing attacks and they all have a ridiculous attack range.
Demon Slayers have a wide variety of mobbing attacks from their 2nd-4th job.
The sames goes for Kanna, except she has more offensive reach than a Demon Slayer and a Battle Mage.

I'm not sure if Kanna attacks faster than a BaM.
I do know that a BaM with all his/her Hyper skills will own any Kanna though. (Until Kanna's hyper skills are released, then someone will eventually determine which is better.)

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
Blohgorn

i dont see kanna being similar to ds play style. i see it being a mage that has a mille aiguilles type skill, with summons that make BaMs jealous. other than that i think they are really similar to BaM's with their close range combat playstyle. do you guys think their haja rengekifu (the mille tyle skill) will attacks faster then FB

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
Psydei

I always like the most crappy classes (Bishop, BaM [no hypers], and now Kanna)

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
Momijii

I don't get why people keep saying that she'll play just like a Demon Slayer.

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
toad

BaM lag with teleport? Im pretty sure its not true... Well, the only way to compare is without hyper skills because Kanna don't have them... Let's wait 7 days to see if our Kanna will be the same or different from JMS in therms of damage... If there is no changes...oh well, i would stay with BaM... But Kanna is my second choice, and a third one would be Luminous...

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
Singaporean

@fyeflowlight: unless bam tele is different from mage tele then no, at least not for me

Reply February 20, 2013 - edited
fyeflowlight

[quote=Singaporean]agreed ^

The only char that I think have better hypers (as far as benefiting the class) are cannoneers 100%
Bam hypers are so boss. You can get perm invincibility by the looks of it be telecasting bosses continuously. I don't think your fingers will like you much though...[/quote]

Perm invincibility wud be awesome xD but doesn't tele hav a lag? does that lag last for more than one sec though?

Reply February 19, 2013 - edited
j1mm13valadez

[quote=VolklRacerr]Kanna will be better, no doubt in my mind.
But then... the beloved [b]nerf[/b] comes and then Kanna is below phantom in terms of dps[/quote]

There will be no nerf. Kanna is not an op class, to do decent damage you will actually need funding.

Reply February 19, 2013 - edited
Momijii

[quote=VolklRacerr]Kanna will be better, no doubt in my mind.
But then... the beloved [b]nerf[/b] comes and then Kanna is below phantom in terms of dps[/quote]
Kanna's been out for [i]almost[/i] a year and hasn't received any substantial changes so.... that was a really bad joke.

Reply February 19, 2013 - edited
LittleTLK

I'll play one to see. I'm not switching over unless I find it irresistibly fun being a cute little boy in robes with a fan~

Reply February 19, 2013 - edited
Imaginal

BaM's Damage % is really high with Hyper Skills.
They are not doubt in the top 5 that deal the most % with hyperskills

Reply February 18, 2013 - edited
Singaporean

@AuraShade86: Oh definitely but I just don't feel they help boost the class the way bam and cannon hypers do XP

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited
Momijii

Until Kanna gets hyper skills, it's hard to say. In a hyper-less scenario, I'd say it's pretty close. With hypers (reminder than Kanna has none), BaM trumps her by a land-slide.

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited
AuraShade86

[quote=Singaporean]The only char that I think have better hypers (as far as benefiting the class) are cannoneers 100%[/quote]

ehhh i personally like Vengeance of Angel and no cd snipe too

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited
Singaporean

agreed ^

The only char that I think have better hypers (as far as benefiting the class) are cannoneers 100%
Bam hypers are so boss. You can get perm invincibility by the looks of it be telecasting bosses continuously. I don't think your fingers will like you much though...

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited
AuraShade86

they do not have hyper skills. also BaM has some of the best active hyper skills out of any char

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited
EMSfreeze

as far as i know, JMS didnt release hyperskills for hayato and kanna
correct me if i am wrong

Reply February 17, 2013 - edited