General

I think you should accept the dark look and call it a day, my friend.

Your perm nx selection is big but also quite limited to make full outfit combos/themes that match your character. Dark look is best.

alternative to your dark look : http://imgur.com/Ygs4lUO
I'm sure you have those eyes from the maple hood event .

Totally not biased, but I'm a big fan of green.

They all look equally 4/10

I like the "Dark" one, but I would definitely find another face that suits the look better. Bright eyes seems too innocent for the look you're trying to go for.

Blue 4/10 common "qt blue" style clothing

Dark 7/10 some sort of pompous demon but ew bright eyes

Green 3/10 accidentally used a Beauty Coupon after establishing green theme.

Red 4/10 hene hoe

Black 5/10 do something about the pants