The Ultimate Battle of all Time: Pop Tart vs Toaster Strudel Which is better? The Pop Tart? or the Toaster Strudel? And why? I personally like Pop Tarts. It's the not that the pilsbury item doesn't taste good. It's the fact I have to put the frosting on myself. I absolutely hate that. If it came with the frosting on it, they might be a contender. But for me, Pop Tart wins! (if you're in some other country that has another product, I'm not making an "other" option for you, sorry. But you're free to post what you do like, and just simply cast your vote, or not.)