General

Chat

Anyone wanna read over my paper?

Doing a paper on Romeo and Juliet explaining who I personally think is to blame for all of the tragic events in the story. Anyone care to read and give criticism or suggestions? Thanks!

While reading Romeo and Juliet you can notice that the cause of the tragic events cannot be blamed on one single person. All of the tragic events happen because of a collective "effort" of all the characters. However I personally feel that of all the characters in "Romeo and Juliet" Friar Lawrence is most responsible for the tragic events that befell Romeo and Juliet. He was unable to help Romeo when he needed guidance most, foolishly married Romeo and Juliet for selfish reasons, and gave Juliet the sleeping potion causing her family grief and pain.
When people need guidance they ask for help. Whether it is from a friend, father figure, or relative, they use the guidance of whomever they trust the most. In Romeo's case he trusted Friar Lawrence the most and decided to go to him for advice when he was troubled. In Act II Scene 3 after meeting Juliet, Romeo felt confused as to whether he loved her or not. When he went to Friar Lawrence seeking guidance, Friar Lawrence simply brushed off his love saying that he was simply a child and this would pass over just like his others. This caused Romeo to act by his own poor judgment instead of taking Friar Lawrence's advice. If Friar Lawrence had listened to Romeo and taken him seriously, he could have potentially prevented the engagement/marriage of Rome and Juliet.
In Act 2 Scene 5 after Romeo had shrugged off Friar Lawrence's bad advice about Juliet he proceeded to ask her to marry him. When she agreed, he came to the Friar asking him to marry them. The Friar did not think about Romeo or Juliet, he thought about ending the feud between the two families. He did not give one single thought to the well-being of Romeo and Juliet or the fact that their parents could possibly banish them for this. Any other person with the right intentions would have not married them as they had only known each other for 16 hours, and were still both minors. Because of Friar Lawrence's bad judgment and quick actions he dug Romeo and Juliet's grave.
The final moment in which the Friars advice was needed most, he once again failed. In Act IV Scene I Juliet comes to him in despair saying she was going to be forced to marry Paris and threatened to kill herself. The Friar could have attempted to reason with Juliet and resolve the problem, but instead he gave her the sleeping potion to solve the problem the easy way. He feared that Juliet would give away the secret of Romeo and her being married and that he would get in trouble for marrying them. Instead of taking a risk he acted safely and selfishly by giving her the sleeping potion causing her family grief and putting a hand on the dagger that killed Juliet.
From this it can be concluded that the character who caused most of the tragic events was Friar Lawrence. He acted selfishly and never thought of Romeo or Juliet's well-being throughout the play. Because of this he ultimately was the one to cause their deaths.

June 2, 2013

11 Comments • Newest first

dimo

I think people forget two important facts, one, Juliet was only 13, and two, the entire story spans only 4 days. If anyone is to blame it's themselves for being such spoiled little brats.

Reply June 3, 2013
onigiri123

@CondemnedSpirit:
Already mentioned but replace the 'you'. If you're doing an analysis then use: 'readers are presented with the notion that the cause...'
Commas,
'Whether it [b]be[/b] from...'
Spelt Romeo wrong->Rome
Are you sure you don't need quotes? Telling of Romeo's confusion is best left for the readers to interpret after giving examples from the text.
Condense the story telling.
Minors? IF you've read the book, Juliet was promised to someone already.At that time, age wasn't a major issue.
Replace 'quick actions'. This phrasing suggests a positive aspect to the Friar.

Your contention at the start disputes your arguments. Re-visit the starting contention and tweak the wording.
Also, rephrase your ending sentence.

I can give you an example starter if you want.

Reply June 3, 2013 - edited
CondemnedSpirit

[quote=Hatchet]You're in grade 10 right?

OT: If I handed this in I would probably get like a 40 lmao.[/quote]

9th

Reply June 3, 2013 - edited
mechibi

[quote=Hatchet]You're in grade 10 right?

OT: If I handed this in I would probably get like a 40 lmao.[/quote]

Tbh it would get a 40
I read this in the 8th grade so i forgot half of the book but i quickly wrote a brief thesis. Its short, i know
Did this on my phone so grammar mistakes
From the first page of the play, William Shakespeare informs the audience the play "Romeo Juliet" is a tragedy. Now who is the one causing the tragedies? It's all the characters, but the one that stands out is Friar Lawrence. This man is the best friend of Romeo. Friar gave bad advice, married the two teenagers, and caused their deaths.

Reply June 3, 2013 - edited
Hatchet

You're in grade 10 right?

OT: If I handed this in I would probably get like a 40 lmao.

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited
CondemnedSpirit

[quote=MadWorld]Don't know about your school, but in my school thi sessay would not even get a C-[/quote]

Probably will get a C-, no one ever taught us how to write a paper anyway.

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited
CondemnedSpirit

[quote=NuggetsOnCrack]-you need to start utilizing commas
-the "you" in the first sentence seems to be a generalization; replace it with "one" or "it"
-for your commentary, don't you need quotes as evidence?[/quote]

Changed in original paper, thanks.

[quote=mechibi]Never write in 2nd person. write one instead of you R and j BY friar first para isnt a thesis, more like 2 paras combined need to fix topic sentences[/quote]

Fixed in orginal paper, thanks.

[quote=LetThereBeFradd]That's an essay? Seems more like a short paragraph.[/quote]

Not an essay, 5 paragraphs.

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited
SoulBlade

You don't want me checking it -.-

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited
mechibi

Never write in 2nd person. write one instead of you
first para isnt a thesis, more like 2 paras combined
need to fix topic sentences

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited
CondemnedSpirit

[quote=MadWorld]Cool! I'm doing a Romeo and Juliet paper too! Is yours only a page essay or the 5 paragraph norm type?
I wish you would have used Quote Evidence.
For example, Friar LAwrence lies when he says, "I then heard a noise from the tomb" (5.3.#).[/quote]

5 paragraph norm type. I normally would use quotes such as that, but my teacher specified that he only wanted us to state the Act and scene.

Reply June 2, 2013 - edited