General

Site

What are the reasons that screens are rejected?

Can someone tell me all the reasons for a drawing screen to be rejected?

One of my drawings were rejected (ill post a link later) and I wanna know why so I can make sure to fix it later.
As far as I see, there's nothin wrong with it.
- I put a character sprite representing the chara on the drawin.
- no nudity
- no gore
- just a girl holdin a basket

edit: http://i.imgur.com/Qa3gBqh.jpg

January 22, 2013

10 Comments • Newest first

MickyBumBum

[quote=Pavchka]I think I got it! I can see a little bit of your keyboard at the bottom. MrBasil makes a point out of rejecting drawings that haven't been cropped properly. He rejected one of my drawings because part of my scanner was visible. If you cut that piece out and perhaps that very tiny bit of empty space at the top right corner as well I don't see any reason why he should reject it a second time. It's adorable; very nice colouring and it's traditional artwork (as in no Wacom + SAI) as well. You're going to score bonus points from the community with that.[/quote]

I hadoken'd my laptop for that. hnnng. Thank you, I'll make sure the crop it. - o -"

Reply January 22, 2013
Pavchka

[quote=MickyBumBum]@Pavchka: http://i.imgur.com/Qa3gBqh.jpg
:-) Thank you in advance, the dimensions are 1024 x something smaller than 2000[/quote]

I think I got it! I can see a little bit of your keyboard at the bottom. MrBasil makes a point out of rejecting drawings that haven't been cropped properly. He rejected one of my drawings because part of my scanner was visible. If you cut that piece out and perhaps that very tiny bit of empty space at the top right corner as well I don't see any reason why he should reject it a second time. It's adorable; very nice colouring and it's traditional artwork (as in no Wacom + SAI) as well. You're going to score bonus points from the community with that.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
MickyBumBum

@Pavchka: http://i.imgur.com/Qa3gBqh.jpg
:-) Thank you in advance, the dimensions are 1024 x something smaller than 2000

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
Pavchka

[quote=MickyBumBum]When I get home from work, ill post it, thanks a lot :-)[/quote]

Right, looking forward to seeing it.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
MickyBumBum

[quote=Pavchka]He's not very consistent though. I don't know if you witnessed that female Horntail debacle... Hooooooooo boy. ><

Could you upload the picture to Photobucket or so and post it here in this thread? I'm not aware of all requirements a picture must meet, but I'll do my best to find whatever's preventing MrBasil from accepting it.[/quote]

When I get home from work, ill post it, thanks a lot :-)

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
Pavchka

[quote=WorkOfArt]-Bad drawing
-Not very representative
-MrBasil doesn't like it
-Unrelated
-Not enough maple
-too sexual even if no nudity

@HastyHeist
Except only mrbasil accepts and looks at screens, not mods.[/quote]

He's not very consistent though. I don't know if you witnessed that female Horntail debacle... Hooooooooo boy. ><

[quote=MickyBumBum]- I thought it was one of my better works
- was bigger exact replica of the character
- was maplestory
- was maple character
- modestly dress character, flat chest, no hips

So mr. B just hates it T_T[/quote]

Could you upload the picture to Photobucket or so and post it here in this thread? I'm not aware of all requirements a picture must meet, but I'll do my best to find whatever's preventing MrBasil from accepting it.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
Doutei

too much white space.
little to no resemblance.
drawing first - bannedstory after. (haven't we all?)
unrelated space.
file size exceeding limits.
dimensions too large.
wrong file type.
unreadable - corrupt submission.
too much updating old screens with newer versions.
intolerable themes
needz moar photoshop lighting/ too much photoshop mashing.

really long list.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
MickyBumBum

[quote=WorkOfArt]-Bad drawing
-Not very representative
-MrBasil doesn't like it
-Unrelated
-Not enough maple
-too sexual even not nude[/quote]
- I thought it was one of my better works
- was bigger exact replica of the character
- was maplestory
- was maple character
- modestly dress character, flat chest, no hips

So mr. B just hates it T_T

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
Quasar

I made a comic with gore once and it got accepted, and a few drawings are not that good and got accepted, so it's a mystery why your screen did not get accepted.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited
WorkOfArt

-Bad drawing
-Not very representative
-MrBasil doesn't like it
-Unrelated
-Not enough maple
-too sexual even if no nudity

@HastyHeist
Except only mrbasil accepts and looks at screens, not mods.

Reply January 22, 2013 - edited