General

At what point is too much %magic att/ %att worse then %total

I hear that %magic att/ %att is better then %total, but does it ever get to a point when you get too much %magic att, and it would be more beneficial to get %total? Or is %magic att/att always better?

October 16, 2014

8 Comments • Newest first

GoXDS

there's never a case where you'd want %Total. you'd always take %Boss over %Total. thus is becomes a question of when is too much %Boss.
unless ofc you really don't want %Boss Neb and debating between %Matk and %Total, but generally since you should have a lot more %Boss than %Matk, %Matk wins (though I'd personally go for %Ignore in this case)

Reply October 16, 2014
Revolutionist

[quote=redherring]Unless I'm mistaken, Dark Aura gives TD, not %m.atk. Though your range will be much higher with TD, %m.atk should pretty much always be the better option.[/quote]

ADA has always been % Attack/Magic Attack, not Total Damage. It stacked additively with Echo when the Attack/Magic Attack stat still showed in the previous stat window UI (from gMS 1.37 to 1.48).

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited
redherring

[quote=ppaauull789]Well my main is a battle mage (auras give %magic att), and Ive cubbed alot of my equipment for solely %magic att. So Im just worried if I try and recube a piece of equip that has mainly %total and some %matt, to get it to have all %matt that it would lower my damage rather then raise it.[/quote]

Unless I'm mistaken, Dark Aura gives TD, not %m.atk. Though your range will be much higher with TD, %m.atk should pretty much always be the better option.

Anecdata: I recubed a wand from 21% TD/15% m.atk to 36% m.atk, and did much more damage with the latter.

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited
ppaauull789

Well my main is a battle mage (auras give %magic att), and Ive cubbed alot of my equipment for solely %magic att. So Im just worried if I try and recube a piece of equip that has mainly %total and some %matt, to get it to have all %matt that it would lower my damage rather then raise it.

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited
Doutei

usually the question is asked regarding when is it too much boss% lul.
so it'd be better to ditch total damage and look for lines of Matt% or boss% accordingly to your needs.

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited
Elufu

Depends on the class but generally it's safe to assume %Matt/Att is better than %TD (Wild Hunters have a lot of ATT% from their skills, so they'd rather have %TD or %Boss).

Ideally you'd want to juggle between %Matt/Att and %Boss (and possibly Ignore Defense%) when selecting equipment potential/stats.

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited
UAPaladin

Unless you have more %m.att than %TD + %boss (which is basically never), then %m.att will always be better

Reply October 16, 2014 - edited