General

Gin Tama
Natsume's Book of Friends
Mushishi
Hajime no Ippo
Monster

Heartcatch Precure
Zettai Bouei Leviathan
Smile Precure
Ojamajo Doremi
Arad Senki Slap Up Party

space adventure cobra
black lagoon
ushio and tora
kyou kara ore wa
inuyasha

okay I don't watch anime... often.

Wedding Peach
Bleach
Blood+
Inuyasha
Elfen Lied

All are very enjoyable anime.

@bloodIsShed: It's not sarcasm.

[quote=Hatchet]Das sum good tayste mang[/quote]
y tank u mang (no sarcasm i hope)

my top 5 might change since i have yet to watch supposedly great animes such as Afterstory, Shingeki (supposedly a masterpiece), etc

[quote=bloodIsShed]Tokyo Magnitude 8
The Idolmaster
Spice & Wolf
Usagi Drop
Hanasaku Iroha[/quote]

Das sum good tayste mang

Code Geass
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood
Steins;Gate
Clannad series
Angel Beats!

[quote=DiegoZeta]No it's not. It's not even in the top 10 within it's genre.[/quote]

You seem cool diego, and your shout for " Memories" , such a great movie , all 3 are quality

ANIMATRIX! The guy who made the " World record" made samurai champloo, redline,Vampire hunter D

Honestly if anyone hasn't checked out the animatrix, do it! same with Memories

Ok diego, Code Guess vs other mech anime, or if you think its a different genre , where does it belong ?

My View: Watched Code Guess year's ago , thought it was very good, before coming onto the basil forums I couldn't remember a single thing about it , but I know it's on of the best mech anime's , in comparison to Gundam.
Watched gundam year's ago, probably every episode looking back and re-watching now, seem's a little slow and lot's of shouting , but not as much action as I remember in comparison to Gurran Lageen.

You seem to have watched a lot of weird anime's , whats your top mech anime's if code guess is not one of them?

Code geass is the best anime hands down.

[quote=Jrosen]Monogatari Series>All that other crap[/quote]

YES, YES FINALLY SOMEONE WHO AGREES WITH ME F5

edit: although on my first post i already added my top 5, i might just add some honorable mentions:
samurai champloo, one piece, hajime no ippo, steins gate, angel beats

[quote=Dauntaro]Did you just list Naruto and ARIA in the same post? But why? Original Naruto's best moments were filler episodes...
Also, Zabuza. We can't forget Zabuza.[/quote]
I don't get what you're trying to convey. I'm guessing you're surprised I put Naruto in my top 15?

Did you just list Naruto and ARIA in the same post? But why? Original Naruto's best moments were filler episodes...

Also, Zabuza. We can't forget Zabuza.

[quote=Dauntaro][i]looks through entire thread[/i]
[i][b]Only one mention of Madoka, by me[/b][/i][/quote]
I'll be the second

My top five (in order, +/- 0.5)
1) Code Geass 10/10
2) Madoka Magica 10/10
3) Usagi Drop 10/10
4) Steins;Gate 9.5/10
5) Gintama 9.5/10

Honorable Mentions (top 15, not in order, all in the range of 8~9/10):
FMA: Brotherhood
Fate/Zero
Cowboy Bebop
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Clannad (After Story only, 1st season was just all right)
Naruto (the original series, not Shippuden-crap)
Monogatari series
Hajime no Ippo
Aria the 'xxxxx' series
Nana

Five anime that I consider grossly overrated (besides the big three):
SAO 6/10
Suzumiya Haruhi series (including the movie) 5.5/10
K-ON series 5/10
Angel Beats! 6/10
SnK 7/10 (still a good anime, but not 'the best anime ever' as many like to claim).

*My average is a 5/10.

Monogatari Series>All that other crap

Gintama
Psycho-Pass
Ouran High School Host Club
Durarara!
Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai

[quote=Dauntaro][i]looks through entire thread[/i]
[i][b]Only one mention of Madoka, by me[/b][/i][/quote]

one piece.

"looks though entire thread. only 2 mentioned one piece."

shame on you anime/manga lovers! shame on you!

[i]looks through entire thread[/i]
[i][b]Only one mention of Madoka, by me[/b][/i]

[No order]
TWGOK
Welcome to the NHK
baka to test to shoukanjuu
clannad + After story
Zero no Tsukaima

I used to only have 3 anime I could name off the top of my head I liked a lot, but recent anime is pretty darn good and don't let anyone tell you otherwise.

1.) Puella Magi Madoka Magica - I'll never let anyone tell me it's bad or whatever. It's mostly personal taste in the style of the anime, the composition of the score, and, you know, the vast amounts of NanoFate-level shiptease.
2.) Senki Zesshou Symphogear - ALL the singing. The only reason I watched Kamen Rider Kiva was for the singing in the insert songs. Now replace Koji Seto with a lot of all-star qt female seiyuu, change the composer to Elements Garden, and just have a generally better story/production. Oh god so good.
3.) Shigofumi - A hidden gem of the late 2000s. Got overshadowed by things like Gurren Lagann and whatever else was airing at the time, so it fell just below the Manabi Line, I think. Despite its relatively small budget and low "excitement" factor, it was really, really good. Story, feels, premise, characters, music, all of it. WARNING: Has been described as a love-it-or-hate-it anime.
4.) El Cazador de la Bruja - The epitome of "smash a bunch of crap together and hope it turns out well" in anime, and it turned out really freakin' well. There's a lot of unexplained crap thrown in there for the cool factor and it works out and there're about five layers of fake symbolism hiding the real symbolism and it's REALLY REALLY CUTE and throws references EVERYWHERE and and and the charm of it all is wonderful.
5.) Gakuen Utopia Manabi Straight - Jesus god all the feels I got from this anime and it's a generic (premise-wise) slice of life with slightly disturbing character designs how did it affect me so deeply?

@Irony:
TBH i haven't watched them, yet. I have them all downloaded, i am just trying to get through some other stuff first because KnK is like 10+hours.

Black Rock Shooter!
Cowboy Bebop
Beelzubub
Bleach

those 4 stand out , a million others could fill the next slot

[no order]
Detective Conan [the amount of episodes]
Toriko [food / cooking and best of all Yun the penguin <3]
Rockman [Childhood classic + wonderful never released music]
Gintama [Jokes/ comedy /parody and mocking of other anime/manga]
Aquarion. [Music and mechas trembling ontop of a love story]

Aside from Aquarion, any anime i can watch over an over without getting too sick of the plot/stories/music is number 1 on my list.

[quote=razormana]@Irony
Kara no kyoukai is an episodic movie series, it is like the melancholy of haruhi suzumiya. In that it was released in a non-chronological order, but can be watched in chronological order.

OT:
D.Gray-Man
Another
Shiki
Ga Rei: Zero
Saki[/quote]

Yea it's not in chronological order but I heard the 5th movie in particular was quite amazing, I'm worried that i could possibly miss stuff from the previous movies though

@Irony
Kara no kyoukai is an episodic movie series, it is like the melancholy of haruhi suzumiya. In that it was released in a non-chronological order, but can be watched in chronological order.

OT:
D.Gray-Man
Another
Shiki
Ga Rei: Zero
Saki

[quote=memory829]Fate/Zero
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (It's a movie but it's the only anime that deserves a 10/10)
Steins;Gate
Baccano
Kara no Kyoukai 7 (Another movie, but it's just simply amazing)

Edit: Oh, almost forgot, Evangelion.[/quote]

For Kara no Kyoukai:
Do I need to watch the previous 6 to understand 7?
On another note, do I need to watch the previous 4 to understand 5?

Reason being, I've watched the previosu 4 movies half a year ago and I'm afraid that I forgot nearly everything so should I rewatch or continue from 4?

[quote=DiegoZeta]Er, no.

I can think of at least 10 animes that are 10/10 worthy, let alone better.[/quote]

Care to name a few? I wanna see this 10/10 worthy list.
Might consider watching a few from this list depending on whether I've completed it or not.
Not a whole lot of animes worth watching this fall. Monogatari is probably the only one that meets the basic demands.

Fate/Zero
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (It's a movie but it's the only anime that deserves a 10/10)
Steins;Gate
Baccano
Kara no Kyoukai 7 (Another movie, but it's just simply amazing)

Edit: Oh, almost forgot, Evangelion.

I wish this was a top 10 list, would make it far easier (but not really)

Shinsekai yori
Toradora!
Ga-Rei: Zero
Great Teacher Onizuka
Katanagatari

Haven't watched enough to truly have a top 5 yet. It's too close for me to decide one the top 5 lol, many are pretty good for me

Tokyo Magnitude 8
The Idolmaster
Spice & Wolf
Usagi Drop
Hanasaku Iroha

Sword Art Online
Kyoukai no Kanata
Shingeki no Kyojin (Attack on Titan)
Sakuraso No Pet Kanojo
Mirai Nikki

Naruto
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood
Ao No Exorcist
Hataraku Maou Sama
Attack on Titan

Cowboy Bebop
Gintama
One Piece
Hunter x Hunter

and Samurai Champloo, Welcome to the NHK or JoJo

Dragon ball z
Pokemon
SAO
bleach
Naruto

#flameOn

In order

Attack on Titan
Valvrave
Kuroko no Basket
Ao no Exorcist
Log Horizon

Eureka 7
Steins;Gate
Katanagatari
Fate/Zero
Gurren Lagann

the monogatari series
fate zero
SnK
Gurren Lagann
Death Note

Clanand + Afterstory
Toradora

Cowboy Bebop (dub)
Old episodes of One Piece
....

Hm. I can only think of two at the moment.

1) Everything by P.A Works except Red Data Girl
2) Monogatari series

Technically more than 5. Sue me.