General

Chat

Graphic Novels Vs Novels

Tonight, I have to do a lab report for Biology. So naturally, I'm wasting time on Basil. So I figured that I would make a thread that would interest me.

So, I ask you, people of BasilMarket chat section, what's better?

Graphic novels (Comics, Manga, etc) vs Novels (Y'know, with words and all that)

I'm an EXTREMELY heavy manga reader, so I'd say that.

Things to discuss:

-Which is more difficult to write
-Compare styles
-Quality of stories that you've read
-Favorite titles of each type.

Please answer seriously, I'm actually interested in your opinion.

Though, I think I know how it's going to turn out.

September 28, 2012

8 Comments • Newest first

Mewtwo

Most LA teachers will say graphic novels are just as good as reading novels because they teach you how to read pictures

Reply September 28, 2012
cashmoneyinfini

Huh. Just as I predicted, Manga is winning out.

Let's keep it coming.

Reply September 28, 2012
juliacat

I'm sure writing/ illustrating a comic book/manga book is much harder than writing a novel, assuming that a single person is both doing the writing and the drawing. I like how manga/comic books have illustrations to give you a better idea of what's going on. I'm a very big normal-novel reader as well, but it's not as easy getting sucked into a 500 page picture-free book than it is to get sucked into an oftentime, not too thick graphic-filled book.For novels, you've got series like Harry Potter, and with manga/comic books/graphic novels you've got stuff like One Piece.So, all-in-all, I find it more relaxing to read a picture filled book so I don't have to worry about imagining what's going on, so, I side with manga/comic books/graphic novels/ whatever you want to call them.

Reply September 28, 2012
cashmoneyinfini

[quote=LazyLazyLazy]Can you guys recommend me the best fantasy entertainment of both parties.[/quote]

I'm not too sure about the Novel part, but for manga, tell me what type specifically.

Battle Fantasy, Exploration Fantasy, etc?

I'd recommend Hunter X Hunter for Battle Fantasy, I always thought that it was brilliant.

Reply September 28, 2012
Nolen

Can you guys recommend me the best fantasy entertainment of both parties.

Reply September 28, 2012
cashmoneyinfini

@Nayavivant: Elite much? I'd rather be a "Douchbag" who justifies enjoying something different than an elite bastard who calls anyone with preferences different from his own dumb.

Reply September 28, 2012