General

[quote=cherrytigers]27% all stats. It can be used by any job (besides DA) so it will have more potential customers.[/quote]

i disagree about having more potential customers. Generally non xenons try avoiding pure all stats% items because the sellers will price the item as a xenon item & not like a 27% str item

27 all stats if on regular potential only is three top lines of 9 percent all

[quote=cherrytigers]Does this apply for other non-thief jobs as well? If I recall, bowmen have str as a secondary stat and mages have luk etc. Unless these were removed in some patch...? Which is quite possible, but I honestly forgot! [/quote]

Well, stat for stat in the formula, secondary stats [b]do[/b] give 1/4th the amount of range as main stat, the problem is that despite the fact that most equips have all stats nowadays, your base main stat makes it so that main stat% give significantly more range than four times the same amount of secondary stat%.

I'm certain that for all classes that aren't Xenon/DA, 33% main stat beats 27% all stat anyday unless, of course, you have some really weird ap distribution or something.

Of course, for tradeable common equips it's worthwhile to keep %all stat, imo, especially at 27%.

[quote=hydraxide]All merching aside, even if you look at just the thief classes, 27% + 27/4% ~ 34%, so it's still better even for thieves.[/quote]

Does this apply for other non-thief jobs as well? If I recall, bowmen have str as a secondary stat and mages have luk etc. Unless these were removed in some patch...? Which is quite possible, but I honestly forgot!

27% All stats is very hard to come by.
You'd most likely cube another 33% Main stat before getting 27% all stat but hey, what do I know. RNGThings.

[quote=cherrytigers]27% all stats. It can be used by any job (besides DA) so it will have more potential customers.[/quote]

All merching aside, even if you look at just the thief classes, 27% + 27/4% ~ 34%, so it's still better even for thieves.

27% all stats. It can be used by any job (besides DA) so it will have more potential customers.

@yearn must be nice having two secondary stats...

27%all stat > 33%luk for shadower and xenon.
Should also cost more too

33% luk is 1 top line. 27% all stat is 2 top lines.

I would go with 27% all stat.

My money is on 27% all stat.

I'd say luk cause its higher and multiple subclasses benefit from it (not to mention its LUK, the most expensive stat) as to all stat only being efficiently utilized by xenon.

33% is more then 27% so i'd go with the 33 but I'm dumb.
Especially since its luck