General

[quote=Plenair]@sparkshooter: So when I say it's objectively bad, you disagree and say that it's subjectively good. Failfish[/quote]
I have no idea what that means. But your argument gives off the impression that it's a bad anime in every characteristic and perspective.

[quote=Plenair]"You shouldn't compare it to anime blah blah blah blah" It doesn't take a large budget or anything to make a good story line, good characters, and be objectively good. Hell, I other than Ness no one else in this thread bashed on its animation quality or anything, most people like me were referring to its content, which does suck. When I compared it to anime, not sure how it's not obvious, I was comparing it to the content also, unless you assumed I meant the animation quality of RWBY and actual anime were on par on sucking.
@Raginroxas
@Arthenon: You basically just said "People who think it's bad are nazis and people who think it's good are delusional" I think you're the delusional elitist here.
@sparkshooter: You basically just said: "It's decent for people who can tolerate crap" unless by "less high quality" you mean it's actual quality, as in this stuff is good. However: "[b]compared to[/b] popular/[b]good anime [/b] it stands no chance." You basically just acknowledged it's bad so I don't know why you're trying to call me out or defend it.[/quote]
I'm just saying it's only bad because you're the type of person that is very critical of anime. I honestly think it's a fun thing to watch weekly. It's worth my 5-10 minutes. And please don't twist my words around using synonyms like "crap." I can accept that you think it's horrible anime, but there no way of you arguing that it's horrible for everyone. It's good enough for thousands of people to like it. And if there's a decent fan base size, it's a good enough anime.

Kinda disappointing seeing how it is made by the geniuses behind RvB
RvB is da best

Well you shouldnt compare RWBY to anime anyways, it doesn thave amazing budget like most animes do. Anyways i think RWBY is alright, not certainly amazing but it has its moments. For what its worth the battles look pretty good (even though some of the animations look derpy at times) and on top of that the soundtrack is [b]amazing[/b] but im not sure if its everyone's cup of tea Anyways why not check it out? the 1st season is really short from each episode ranging from around 6 to 10 minutes so you dont have much to lose if you do decide to give it a try

Like everybody above,

The action and weapons are really cool.

That's about it; perhaps volume 2 will have some improvement but it's honestly not going to be that great.

[quote=Plenair]A wannabe anime made by people who wanted to make their own anime trying to be good by copying all the troupes and cliches that every popular anime have which are all mostly crap so it's a generic piece of crap that wants to be a generic piece of crap anime and succeeds in it because it's a generic piece of crap and asking why is just stupid as stupid as this anime and this run on sentence since RWBY sucks.

It's bad.
Bad writing
Bad characters
Copy Paste of popular crap
Cool animation but that doesn't mean anything when the content sucks, key example: SAO
Cool non-official stuff, but still sucks
It sucks

[b]Need I say more?[/b][/quote]
This coming from the person who made the "Do You Think You Can Judge Anime" thread.
Honestly, compared to popular/good anime it stands no chance. But it's still decent for people who are able to tolerate less high quality anime.

fight scenes are kinda cool
everything else is vomit-worthy

Action sequences are cool, I guess, but the dialogue is really cringe-y.

[quote=Plenair]Cool animation but that doesn't mean anything when the content sucks, key example: SAO[/quote]

Except the animation is terrible.

thx guys

/thread

[url=http://www.basilmarket.com/forum/2751946/1/#45014401]Plenair says[/url]