General

Chat

Help/Advice for Med School Please

Hi everyone,

I am currently finishing up the 1st semester of my freshman year in college and I had a few questions regarding medical school/the process. I know some of these questions may seem dumb, but I would still love to hear your feedback and/or personal stories.

1) I've heard so many mixed responses about this, but what role does your major play in the application process? Does it matter what you major in? I am currently a Biology major and attempting a Kinesiology minor as well. My reasoning for this was that Biology covers the fundamental courses I need for med school, and Kinesiology would give me a background in Anatomy and Physiology, which would be good to have going in. But I have also heard that majoring in things like Art, Poly-Sci, etc can also be just as effective which confuses me.

2) What extracurricular activities should I be aiming for now and over the course of the next few years? This past semester I worked a student job in the Horticulture department with research involving different species of plants, though it was basically just female dog work to be honest. Next semester I plan on working with one of the local hospitals as a scribe or working inside an ambulance as a volunteer. Where should I go from there? What clubs should I be joining?

3) I sort of messed up big time this semester and ended up with a 89 in Calc. I already had the AP credit for this course, but I wanted to take it again just for an easy A and ended up getting screwed over on the last test (I hate online tests). Also in Bio I currently have an 88 and the only way I can make an A in the course is if I make a 96 or higher on the final tomorrow. So potentially, I could have up to two B's in my first semester. How much would this affect my chances and is there anything I could do to help offset these grades?

Thanks in advance!

December 14, 2013

15 Comments • Newest first

aznseal

@NonSonoFronz: Sadly very little, if any. There are many factors though. Like if a GPA is the same or close, then the student from a more prestigious undergrad is preferred. However, a 4.0 at State University is still better than a 3.5 at Harvard. Also, getting a GPA under 3 from the best universities in the word won't even be good for medical school. However, ADCOM knows it's like comparing apples to oranges so the only way to do apples to apples is MCAT score. Regardless of where you went to school, MCAT weighs in and it sort of lowers the GPA problem. A student at a state school who scores a 35 is theoretically just as good as a Princeton grad with a 35.

If you want to go to a TOP medical school, do well at an undergrad institution that grade deflates because those are usually the most prestigious, or random...(lol Auburn). If you want to to A medical school, it's easier from an easier institution. Although medical schools may see where you went for undergrad, they like higher GPAs overall.

Reply December 15, 2013
NonSonoFronz

[quote=aznseal]1) You can have any major and still go to medical school as long as you do the per-requisites. The only reason a science major is recommended is because it gets you used to the rigor of med school and familiarity in the med school courses and MCAT. I majored in zoology and it was fine. It was a good conversation starter because people would ask why I wasn't pre-vet. Also, some people will tell you not to be a science major because statistically, a higher % of non-science majors get accepted, but it's skewed. Maybe 2 English majors apply and 1 get in while 300 science majors apply and 99 get in. Although 50% of English majors got in as opposed to ~33% of science majors, science majors are still the majority.

2) Anything that interests you and that you can passionately talk about. For me, I worked at a nursing home, taught chemistry, tutored athletes, shadowed doctors, youth leader at church, played intramural basketball, and earned an undergraduate research fellowship. I made my personal statement about how my experiences at the nursing home, as a researcher, and as a teacher lead me to medicine. Just do what you like and stick with it. Remember, quality > quantity. I'd say the only "required" extracurriculars are research, volunteer, and shadowing. Everything else is icing on the cake.

3) Don't sweat it. Just make more As down the road. If you have a 3.7+ GPA and a 30+ MCAT by the time you graduate then you'll be fine. Don't let early Bs discourage you. Just remember that you need to make mostly As, if not all As, from now on.

Source: I got accepted and I'll be a M1 in the fall.

PS: Why do you want to be a doctor?

EDIT: Also, crazypoorer is wrong. Medical schools look at the entire transcript and they pay attention to the rigor of your curriculum; not just your pre-reqs.[/quote]

I have a question about GPA that I've heard mixed answers about.
Do med schools actually take the institution you went to into consideration for your GPA? Because I've heard a mix of yeses and nos.

Because I go to a school that goes hard on grade deflation and it's going to be even worse next year.
I did well this semester but no way could I get this lucky further down the road. So I'm actually thinking about transferring to an easier school if that's the case.

Reply December 14, 2013
aznseal

@letshavesomefun: My stats were above the med school average. I started preparing 2 semesters before I took it, so around 8 months, but I only got to hardcore serous studying like the 2-3 months before.

Reply December 14, 2013
smiles1337

1. The general consensus is that your major really doesn't play much in the application process. As long as you satisfy the school's prerequisite requirements in terms of courses, provided they have any to begin with, then you should be fine whether you choose to pursue a science or non-science degree. Of course it's a little more advantageous to pursue something in science just so that when it comes time for your MCAT, you'll be a bit more adept at learning the material and much of it will be very familiar. I chose to pursue Chemistry because it always interested me in high school and although I equally enjoyed biology, I liked how chemistry made you think and constantly apply your knowledge. I love math so it also gave me the opportunity to take quite a few math classes to satisfy my major, enough so that I only had to take one more math class to have my minor. Additionally, pursuing chemistry allowed me to be much more selective in which biology courses I wanted to take and it exposed me to a new field with courses I would have probably never taken otherwise. There are a lot of other reasons that went into my decision, but I think ultimately academic coherence, pursing something you're interested in (and will likely succeed in), and rigour of your program are much more important in the application process than any specific program.

2. Don't quote me on this, because I'm currently in the application process myself, but I've always felt that there shouldn't be/isn't a set list of extracurricular or volunteering activities that you pursue for the sake of medicine. What's more important is that you choose to pursue activities that you feel passionate about, because after all, if and when it comes time for your interview, sharing these experiences with the interviewers will give them much more insight into who you are as a person, your motivation(s) for pursuing medicine etc. With that being said, I'd imagine the interviewers would be much more interested in the quality of the work you've done, not the quantity. An added bonus, and again don't quote me on this, but if you're able to relate how the activities you've pursued have led you/guided you/will help you on the path to medicine then I think that's great. For me, I've always been a very directed individual and I'm really selective with how I choose to spend my time because I've always wanted to be true to my commitments and be passionate in whatever cause I'm working towards. I've had the opportunity of volunteering over the last couple of years with the Canadian Blood Services, and have led the student group at the university in organizing the monthly blood clinics. I volunteer at the hospital, I'm a tutor for second year Physical Chemistry I and II with a nationwide organization, and I've been working in a research lab since my second year and have received two NSERC summer research grants. I know friends who are currently in medical school who did completely different things from being a dancer teacher, to teaching piano, to being lif3guards (Basil is censoring me), and one barely had any extracurricular activities going for her but did a lot of shadowing etc. It's the experience that matters, not what that experience particularly is, granted you should probably aim to do something that's somewhat relatable, probably dealing with people. It's also important to remember that you'll probably be needing a few reference letters later on, so choose activities that you want to contribute to, develop strong relationships with the coordinators/employers/leaders so that when the time comes you'll be set.

3. It depends on the school to be honest. For the most part, I'm inclined to say that it won't have a drastic affect on your GPA as long as you get a lot more As. You should really look into what schools you want to be applying to as early as possibly to see if they have an guidelines regarding grades because for my application process a lot of schools handled GPA differently, and a lot of them had much different cut-offs. Like aznseal said, aim for a 3.7+ GPA and 30+ MCAT and you should be set provided the rest of your application is equally strong.

Reply December 14, 2013
letshavesomefun

[quote=aznseal]1) You can have any major and still go to medical school as long as you do the per-requisites. The only reason a science major is recommended is because it gets you used to the rigor of med school and familiarity in the med school courses and MCAT. I majored in zoology and it was fine. It was a good conversation starter because people would ask why I wasn't pre-vet. Also, some people will tell you not to be a science major because statistically, a higher % of non-science majors get accepted, but it's skewed. Maybe 2 English majors apply and 1 get in while 300 science majors apply and 99 get in. Although 50% of English majors got in as opposed to ~33% of science majors, science majors are still the majority.

2) Anything that interests you and that you can passionately talk about. For me, I worked at a nursing home, taught chemistry, tutored athletes, shadowed doctors, youth leader at church, played intramural basketball, and earned an undergraduate research fellowship. I made my personal statement about how my experiences at the nursing home, as a researcher, and as a teacher lead me to medicine. Just do what you like and stick with it. Remember, quality > quantity. I'd say the only "required" extracurriculars are research, volunteer, and shadowing. Everything else is icing on the cake.

3) Don't sweat it. Just make more As down the road. If you have a 3.7+ GPA and a 30+ MCAT by the time you graduate then you'll be fine. Don't let early Bs discourage you. Just remember that you need to make mostly As, if not all As, from now on.

Source: I got accepted and I'll be a M1 in the fall.

PS: Why do you want to be a doctor?

EDIT: Also, crazypoorer is wrong. Medical schools look at the entire transcript and they pay attention to the rigor of your curriculum; not just your pre-reqs.[/quote]
Thanks for all the helpful information. My father is a physician as well as the majority of our relatives so early on I kind of felt pressured by my family. It wasn't until he asked me to come shadow at one of the hospitals that I really fell in love with medicine. Seeing how much physicians are able to help others and the amount of respect they get just seems so worth all the effort. Plus it is an incredibly stable job. I don't know if those are the right reasons, but I really do want to go to med school. If I may ask, what was your overall GPA in college? MCAT score? When did you start preparing for the MCAT?

Reply December 14, 2013
aznseal

1) You can have any major and still go to medical school as long as you do the per-requisites. The only reason a science major is recommended is because it gets you used to the rigor of med school and familiarity in the med school courses and MCAT. I majored in zoology and it was fine. It was a good conversation starter because people would ask why I wasn't pre-vet. Also, some people will tell you not to be a science major because statistically, a higher % of non-science majors get accepted, but it's skewed. Maybe 2 English majors apply and 1 get in while 300 science majors apply and 99 get in. Although 50% of English majors got in as opposed to ~33% of science majors, science majors are still the majority.

2) Anything that interests you and that you can passionately talk about. For me, I worked at a nursing home, taught chemistry, tutored athletes, shadowed doctors, youth leader at church, played intramural basketball, and earned an undergraduate research fellowship. I made my personal statement about how my experiences at the nursing home, as a researcher, and as a teacher lead me to medicine. Just do what you like and stick with it. Remember, quality > quantity. I'd say the only "required" extracurriculars are research, volunteer, and shadowing. Everything else is icing on the cake.

3) Don't sweat it. Just make more As down the road. If you have a 3.7+ GPA and a 30+ MCAT by the time you graduate then you'll be fine. Don't let early Bs discourage you. Just remember that you need to make mostly As, if not all As, from now on.

Source: I got accepted and I'll be a M1 in the fall.

PS: Why do you want to be a doctor?

EDIT: Also, crazypoorer is wrong. Medical schools look at the entire transcript and they pay attention to the rigor of your curriculum; not just your pre-reqs.

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
crazypoorer

[quote=letshavesomefun]I'm just worried that I'll end up screwing up my GPA from a bunch of B's...[/quote]

If you can't get higher than a B, then you can't really do anything about it can you? After 1 or 2 years in college, you might realize you don't want to be a doctor or nurse or whatever you wanted to be.

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
letshavesomefun

I'm just worried that I'll end up screwing up my GPA from a bunch of B's...

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
crazypoorer

1. You can get into any graduate/medical/pharmacy/etc school with the required test scores/gpa/classes.
2. Get an internship or volunteer experience or even some research.
3. Medical schools don't look at your grades as a whole only. They look at the classes that are required for you to get in to their school and what you got in them.

This is basically almost the same as getting into college from high school...

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
letshavesomefun

[quote=Keane]Let me guess, this was your parents choice to go to med school.[/quote]

Originally it was but towards the end of high school I started to develop my own interest for the field.

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
Kid24

1. Med school doesn't care about what major you are as long as you do the required pre-req+ mcat, letter or rec
2. Undergraduate research, shadow doctors at hospital, volunteer at hospital, getting your EMT license, list can go on (more you do, more it looks good)
3. Idk how your school works but most schools you're not allowed to make up a course grade unless you get a C- which is failing in some schools, a D or an F. I say no point to retake it.. you're doing fine. I know people that have gotten B's on Ochem, Biochem and still gotten into med school

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
DrHye

Look up information on the program at your school and find some of the people in charge of advising/admissions for the program. That's what I did when I changed majors to aim for my school's education program. He walked me through all the requirements and what I need to do in preparation

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
Nolen

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/pre-med-medical-school/
Here's a forum for college related stuff

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited
HolyDragon

1. The people who do arts and other stuff did the pre-req for med. You are fine, keep up the GPA.

2. No idea, you're doing a good job in my opinion.

3. Just work it off with other classes.

Reply December 14, 2013 - edited